Panama Judgement Points Of Honrable Justice Ejaz Afzal Khan


23.                Having thus considered we sum up the case as under:

no aboveboard or undisputed documentary evidence has been brought on the record to show that respondent No. 1 defaulted in the payment of tax as far as his assets as declared in the tax returns are concerned; nothing significant has come forth against respondents No. 9 and 10 as could justify the issuance of the direction asked for. However, sufficient material, as highlighted in para 16 above, has surfaced on the record which prima facie shows that respondent No. 1, his dependents and benamidars acquired assets in the early nineties and thereafter which being disproportionate to his known means of income call for a thorough investigation. In the normal circumstances this job could well be done by NAB, but when its Chairman, in view of his conduct he has demonstrated in Hudaibya’s case by not filing an appeal against a split verdict of the Lahore High Court, appears to be indifferent and even unwilling to perform his part, we are constrained to constitute a joint investigation team (JIT) which would consist of the following members:

  1. a senior Officer of the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA), not below the rank of Additional Director General who shall head the team having firsthand experience of investigation of white collar crime and related matters;

ii)        a representative of the National Accountability Bureau (NAB);

iii)         a nominee of the Security & Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) familiar with the issues of money laundering and white collar crimes;

iv)        a nominee of the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP);

v)        a seasoned Officer of Inter Services Intelligence (ISI) nominated by its Director General; and  

vi)        a seasoned Officer of Military Intelligence (M.I.) nominated by its Director General.


24.                The Heads of the aforesaid departments/ institutions shall recommend the names of their nominees for the JIT within seven days from today which shall be placed before us in chambers for nomination and approval. The JIT shall investigate the case and collect evidence, if any, showing that respondent No. 1 or any of his dependents or benamidars owns, possesses or has acquired assets or any interest therein disproportionate to his known means of income. Respondents No. 1, 7 and 8 are directed to appear and associate themselves with the JIT as and when required. The JIT may also examine the evidence and material, if any, already available with the FIA and NAB relating to or having any nexus with the possession or acquisition of the aforesaid flats or any other assets or pecuniary resources and their origin. The JIT shall submit its periodical reports every two weeks before a Bench of this Court constituted in this behalf. The JIT shall complete the investigation and submit its final report before the said Bench within a period of sixty days from the date of its constitution. The Bench thereupon may pass appropriate orders in exercise of its powers under Articles 184(3), 187(2) and 190 of the Constitution including an order for filing a reference against respondent No. 1 and any other person having nexus with the crime if justified on the basis of the material thus brought on the record before it.

25.                It is further held that upon receipt of the reports, periodic or final of the JIT, as the case may be, the matter of disqualification of respondent No. 1 shall be considered and appropriate orders, in this behalf, be passed, if so required.  

26.                We would request the Hon’ble Chief Justice to constitute a Special Bench to ensure implementation of this judgment so that the investigation into the allegations may not be left in a blind alley.  

(Visited 24 time, 1 visit today)

About Laiba Eshal

I always dreamed to write and share my views with other people but due to busy life schedule I didn't find time for this. Once I thought why not to have my own blog where not only I share my views but also make it very informative and interesting for all. I started and with the help of friends it started creeping. I was unable to give time to pakfunny but now I am trying to spare some time for it. More interestingly I am much interested in spreading laughter in people than sharing my own views but I will do this too.

Check Also

Junaid Jamshed Chitral

Junaid Jamshed Was On Board PIA Fligh PK-661 Which Is Missing On Chitral Islamabad Route

According to PIA sources it’s flight PK-661 is missing on Chitral Islamabad route. Sources confirmed …